Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PS's avatar

Beautiful article. But I sincerely hope you are incorrect. I can't bear the thought of so many conscious beings capable of suffering and grief. The solipsist route has less heartbreak.

Expand full comment
J. M. Elliott's avatar

Diodorus Siculus records a piece of ancient “barbarian” wisdom attributed to the Scythian sage Anacharsis, one of the Seven Sages of ancient Greece. When asked by Croesus: "Whom do you consider to be the bravest of living beings?" he replied, "The wildest animals; for they alone willingly die in order to maintain their freedom."

Then when asked: "Whom do you judge to be the most just of living beings?" Anacharsis answered, "The wildest animals; for they alone live in accordance with nature, not in accordance with laws; since nature is a work of God, while law is an ordinance of man, and it is more just to follow the institutions of God than those of men."

Then Croesus was sure he would stump him: "And are the beasts, then, also the wisest?" And Anacharsis agreed that they were: "The peculiar characteristic of wisdom consists in showing a greater respect to the truth which nature imparts than to the ordinance of the law."

Perhaps, as you suggest, there are trade offs that come with our heightened complexity, and not all of them necessarily enhance our general consciousness.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts