Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dawson Eliasen's avatar

I just think this situation is so completely bonkers. The policy/legality of it seems sort of irrelevant when it is just so obviously terrible. For instance, the Twitter API (which I’ve actually used, and yes it is trivial to get a token and start collecting data)--I am sure the terms of use disallow building anything that competes with Twitter, and I bet Substack was actually in violation of those terms if they were using the Twitter API to develop Notes, or even during/prior to the development of Notes. But then you ban them from the API! You revoke the token! You don’t go on this weird power trip! I mean what the hell.

And I agree with your general feelings about Notes. Substack said that it will be better than Twitter because it will be funded by subscriptions, not ads, and I’m sure that’s true. I’m sure it will be better than Twitter for a lot of reasons, because Twitter is pretty bad. But that doesn’t mean I want Substack working on it. I would really prefer if Substack was a platform absolutely 100% dedicated to long-form content and small networks. Notes doesn’t help me as a writer, it only helps Substack bring in more users + revenue, and at the cost of focus being placed on the things that actually do help writers.

Expand full comment
Spencer Orenstein Lequerica's avatar

The Gossip Trap is the best single piece of writing I have encountered on Substack, so I have to say that I largely agree with your take here.

I want to share one point related to Notes . I was invited to test Notes in beta as a reader. I was initially skeptical, even slightly hostile, to the idea. I told the team as much in the product test that I did. I value Substack because it has connected me with writing that manages to deliver me into a state of reading flow--where I am immersed in the mind of another human. I even used your ideas from the Gossip Trap to write an analogy of how Substack delivers the best experiences of the middle school cafeteria--being together with your friends and exploring the world together--as opposed to the worst aspects, basically everything you're talking about in this post.

I'm not sure if Notes will stay this way, but thus far it has mostly recreated the aspects that I value about Substack but on a more interactive scale. For example, the other night I was having simultaneous discussions about basketball (with a writer I've read for 20 years) and free will (with someone I'd never seen before encountering them on Notes). It made me feel like a piece of technology was bridging a gap to enable meaningful human connection in a way that I haven't felt since the early 00s when I was a regular on a few random message boards.

Expand full comment
42 more comments...

No posts