Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr Andreas Matthias's avatar

Perhaps the problem is amplified by the opening up of discourses whose participation should be limited. Scientific disagreement is a necessary part of science and could be handled within science, but that fails when suddenly the public takes part in this discourse. "Disagreement" within a community of experts and "misinformation" of the public should have been clearly separated by barriers that would separate the populations that take part in each discourse. It is by opening up unfinished and disputed science to the public view that scientists get into trouble with the public by doing what they are supposed to be doing, i.e. criticising their science (but not in public). Access to all the world's information through the internet is not necessarily only a good thing. Gatekeepers, controlled channels that disseminate information to the public and expert disputes behind closed doors might have allowed for a level of freedom in scientific discourse that we have now lost. Just a thought. I'm not sure if this is even correctly diagnosed, but perhaps it would be worth looking into. -- Thanks for that inspiring article!

Expand full comment
Peter Watts's avatar

It occurs to me I tend to weigh in here only when I disagree with you, which seems a bit cranky. So: nice job, dude. Solid points. Although I expect you'll get some blowback from the slippery-slope crowd.

Also, regarding Wuhan: have you heard about the hybrid lab-leak-wet-market hypothesis? I know a source with a source claiming there's at least some evidence that covid did in fact originate in a lab, where some underpaid low-level flunkie was told to dispose of infected experimental animals— and, being both underpaid and not especially savvy on the whole epidemiological front, then sold those animals to the local wet market to make a few extra RMB.

Haven't been able to find any independent corroboration. Wonder if you might have read something.

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts