9 Comments
User's avatar
Roger’s Bacon's avatar

A theme that I love from Revelations and this piece (and one that speaks to your background as a scientist) - the vertiginous self-doubt of pursuing a mystery and questioning whether or not there even is a mystery in the first place (and in the process questioning whether you have begun to lose your grasp on reality).

Bravo, Borges would like this one I think. Ok now it's time for me to write that Borges-inspired short story I've been putting off...

Expand full comment
Erik Hoel's avatar

Wow good catch, yeah that's become a running theme without me really trying. I think it's from working on developing scientific theories of consciousness, which itself is so difficult to get a solid logical handle on.

I think that the occasional Borges-style short fiction work well mixed in with a normally nonfiction newsletter. I haven't seen a pure or even majority fiction substack that has done well. I'm watching substacks like Salman Rushdie's to see how successful they are at this.

Expand full comment
Roger’s Bacon's avatar

Yea I would say it definitely comes from your interest in consciousness, I don't think molecular biologists have this feeling quite as often lol.

I think it's really tough with fiction, going to be hit or miss for so many people. There is a much larger conversation to be had about the decline in fiction reading, but maybe especially on substack people are going to be much more turned off if they read a boring piece of fiction vs. non-fiction (well at least I learned something...).

Expand full comment
llull's avatar

Are you familiar with Ramon Llull? I got a copy of DIALOGOS: Ramon Llull's Method of Thought and Artistic Practice. Incredible resource to supplement Yates. You also might like the work of Michel Beaujour on rhetoric.

Expand full comment
Erik Hoel's avatar

I am, I once read: https://www.amazon.com/Logic-Art-Memory-Universal-Language/dp/0226728269/ which has some very good analyses of Llull's work. Had not heard of DIALOGOS though, sounds interesting.

Expand full comment
llull's avatar

I have this too, but haven’t read yet. Nice to meet you!

Expand full comment
Holy Writ's avatar

I really enjoyed this. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Erik Hoel's avatar

Thank you for reading! It's always a bit risky to do a short story in what is normally an essay series, but it worked out I think

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 5, 2022Edited
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Erik Hoel's avatar

Hey Batislu - thanks! And haha, don't worry, you're not the enemy, I think explainable AI is important (of course, I do wish we'd just drop the whole thing, in the end). It's interesting to consider the difference between an index-based memory and associative memory. In fact, one reason why I myself practiced by never really used the art of memory is that I didn't feel that it was *real knowledge* i.e., things stored there weren't quite part of my associative web. In a sense, all the mystic systems people introduced historically were ways to attempt to solve this problem, and build a semantic web on top of the standard "X is stored here" version of memory palaces that make them incredibly good for rote memorization but not-so-good for incorporating knowledge in a way that's accessible to the rest of your everyday cognition.

Expand full comment